Upgrading from a Tesla Model 3 or Model Y: Is the Crossover Worth It?

The Tesla Model 3 and Model Y are two of the most popular electric vehicles (EVs) on the market. They offer a combination of performance, range, and features that have made them a favorite among EV shoppers. But if you’re already a Tesla owner, you may be wondering if it’s worth upgrading to the Crossover.

The decision to upgrade from a Tesla Model 3 to a Model Y, or vice versa, is a significant consideration for many electric vehicle (EV) enthusiasts. Both the Model 3 and Model Y offer unique features and benefits, and the decision to upgrade depends on individual preferences, lifestyle, and driving needs. In this article, we will explore the factors to consider when contemplating an upgrade from a Tesla Model 3 to a Model Y, or from a Model Y to a Model 3.

Cabin Space and Comfort

One of the primary differences between the Tesla Model 3 and Model Y is the cabin space. The Model Y offers significantly more interior room compared to the Model 3, providing a more spacious and comfortable driving experience. The Model Y also boasts more luggage space, which is more convenient to access thanks to the hatch. If you prioritize interior space and cargo capacity, upgrading to the Model Y could be a sensible choice.

Here’s a table summarising the key interior differences between the three models:

Feature	Tesla Model 3	Tesla Model Y	Crossover
Seating comfort	Supportive and comfortable	Supportive and comfortable	Extremely comfortable with optional heated and cooled seats
Infotainment system	15-inch touchscreen	15-inch touchscreen	17-inch touchscreen with upgraded software
Cargo space	15 cubic feet	68 cubic feet	88 cubic feet with optional fold-down rear seats

Ride Quality and Driving Dynamics

The ride quality and driving dynamics of the Model 3 and Model Y differ due to their distinct body styles. The Model 3 offers a firmer and more agile ride, suitable for those who prefer a sportier driving experience. On the other hand, the Model Y provides a more supple and compliant ride, making it a comfortable choice for daily commuting and long journeys[1]. Consider your preferences for ride comfort and driving dynamics when contemplating an upgrade.

Here’s a table summarizing the key differences between the three models:

Feature	Tesla Model 3	Tesla Model Y	Crossover
Body style	Sedan	Crossover SUV	Crossover SUV
Seating capacity	5	5	7
Cargo space	15 cubic feet	68 cubic feet	88 cubic feet
Range	267-353 miles	330-387 miles	400-500 miles
0-60 mph	3.1-5.8 seconds	3.5-5.1 seconds	2.9-4.8 seconds
Starting price	$46,990	$51,990	$69,990

Pricing and Affordability

From a pricing perspective, the Model 3 is priced lower than the Model Y, making it a more affordable option for budget-conscious buyers. The Model 3 starts at around $39,000, while the Model Y is priced at around $44,000, before incentives and other savings. If affordability is a key consideration, sticking with the Model 3 or upgrading to a newer Model 3 variant could be a sensible decision.

Here’s a table summarizing the starting prices for the three models:

Model	Starting Price
Tesla Model 3	$46,990
Tesla Model Y	$51,990
Crossover	$6

Range and Performance

The Model 3 and Model Y offer similar range and performance capabilities, with both vehicles delivering impressive acceleration and driving range. The Model 3 gets more range on a full charge than the Model Y with the same powertrain, making it a compelling choice for those who prioritize driving range and efficiency. Consider your driving habits and the importance of range when evaluating an upgrade.

Here’s a table summarizing the key performance differences between the three models:

Feature	Tesla Model 3	Tesla Model Y	Crossover
0-60 mph	3.1-5.8 seconds	3.5-5.1 seconds	2.9-4.8 seconds
Top speed	145-162 mph	124-135 mph	150-170 mph
Handling	Responsive and fun to drive	Responsive and fun to drive	Extremely responsive and fun to drive with optional track mode

User Experience and Features

Both the Model 3 and Model Y share many interior elements and software features, offering a seamless and user-friendly experience. However, the Model Y provides additional features such as reclining rear seats and a more upright, crossover-style seating position, enhancing passenger comfort and versatility. If these features are important to you, upgrading to the Model Y could be a sensible choice.

Real-World Experiences

Real-world experiences from Tesla owners who have upgraded from a Model 3 to a Model Y or vice versa can provide valuable insights into the decision-making process. These experiences can offer firsthand accounts of the differences in driving experience, interior space, and overall satisfaction with the upgrade. Engaging with the EV community and seeking feedback from owners who have made similar upgrades can provide valuable perspectives.

Here’s a table summarizing the key range and efficiency differences between the three models:

Feature	Tesla Model 3	Tesla Model Y	Crossover
EPA-estimated range	267-353 miles	330-387 miles	400-500 miles
MPGe	117-142 MPGe	112-126 MPGe	120-140 MPGe
Charging time	30 minutes to 80% with a Supercharger	30 minutes to 80% with a Supercharger	20 minutes to 80% with a new Supercharger

In conclusion, the decision to upgrade from a Tesla Model 3 to a Model Y, or from a Model Y to a Model 3, depends on a range of factors, including cabin space, ride quality, pricing, range, and user experience. Consider your individual preferences, driving needs, and budget when evaluating an upgrade. Real-world experiences from Tesla owners who have made similar upgrades can offer valuable insights and help inform your decision.